Having commented on the Opening Ceremony of the Commonwealth Games, I must comment on the Closing. Not least because I was there. Thanks to some last minute, and free, tickets.
We had a good time. Especially as we didn’t pay for the tickets. If I’d paid for the tickets I would have been disappointed.
The things that were the most fun were the things that make Melbourne Melbourne. And I don’t mean footballers. I mean that:
- the program sellers on the way in, all 500,000 of them, were spruiking their hearts out with appropriate levity: “Come on, did you see the opening ceremony, did you get what was happening with that duck? You know you need a program to have any idea what’s going on!”
- the biggest cheer of the night was for the new cult hero of Melbourne, our Lord Mayor John So. And that cheer happened every single time his name was mentioned. Why is that so Melbourne? Because the games organisers and the State government had tried to elbow him out of the proceedings, and we like nothing better than an underdog here
- the third biggest cheer came when the names of the countries were read out and they got to “Sierra Leone”. With the understanding and sympathy of most (except the immigration department), half the Sierra Leone team disappeared from the Village and went into hiding, planning on seeking asylum, part way through the games. So naturally we love them here
However, all of that was crowd generated. Of the show itself?
- if the section at the end is meant to be a party for the athletes, why did they wheel in John Farnham? Sure, he generated some noise, but I think the organisers were seriously over-estimating the average age of the athletes (hint, it’s not over 45). We have concluded that had Kylie not been sick, she would have been a shoo-in for the job, but in her absence they went with a semi-retired, increasingly rotund, aging pop singer. He did a good job, but those songs are at least 20 years old
- they also only turned up the volume for old whispering Jack. Paul Kelly, Grinspoon and Ben Lee could really have done with an equality of volume
- as much fun as all the 1000 Edna Everage clones were, why build your ceremony around someone who is only available via satellite?
- as for the performance pieces, someone in the paper this morning used the words “high school Rock Eisteddfod”, and I’d have to say that those words sum it up perfectly
- the performance of the Indian delegation promoting the Delhi 2010 games really rather showed us up
All that being said, the weather was brilliant (it’s Melbourne at the end of March and I was sitting outside at 10.30 at night not even remotely needing a long-sleeved top), and those fireworks were pretty damn amazing. Especially when you’re sitting under them, with them criss-crossing the roof of the stadium.
In short, the city itself rocks, the ceremony itself, not so much.